The Seafood Subscription Box: My Top Seven
Table of Contents
ToggleIntroduction
The seafood subscription box has been on the rise for the last 10 years. They took a big hike when the pandemic hit. Seafood, largely because of its nutritional value, is increasing in popularity. Today, you can subscribe to a service that will ship the freshest seafood of your choice to your door each month. Here are my seven best seafood delivery services.
Disclosure
Some of the links in this article may be affiliate links, which can provide compensation to me at no cost to you if you decide to purchase.
What is a fresh seafood subscription box?
A seafood subscription is a service that delivers fresh, sustainably harvested seafood that is wild caught straight to your door. Generally included in the box are a variety of different seafood items, such as fish, shellfish, and even smoked salmon. Alternatively, you can select a box containing a specific fish, such as salmon. Most boxes also come with a recipe card or a link to the company’s recipe section on their website so you can easily prepare a delicious meal.
Most subscription seafood delivery services are very flexible. You get access to your own online portal where you can skip deliveries, change your delivery frequency, change boxes, add items or send a gift box or gift certificate to a friend or relative.
The health benefits of a seafood subscription are many. For one, it’s a great way to get your Omega-3s. Omega-3 fatty acids are essential for heart health, cognitive function, and joint pain relief. They can also help to reduce inflammation throughout the body.
Another benefit of a seafood subscription is that it helps to support sustainable fishing practices. By buying from a company that uses sustainable wild caught fishing methods, you can help to protect our oceans and the delicate ecosystem within them.
Finally, a seafood delivery service is simply a convenient way to enjoy fresh seafood. No more waiting in line at the grocery store or trying to find a spot at the fish market. With a seafood subscription box, you can have delicious, healthy wild caught seafood delivered right to your door.
Here are my top 7 picks for the best wild caught seafood subscription boxes.
1. Fulton Fish Market
2. Sea2Table
3. Sizzlefish
4. Catch Sitka Seafoods
5 Lobster of the Month Club
6. Gourmet Seafood Box
7. Seatopia

Fulton Fish Market
Overview
Opened in 1822, New York City’s Fulton Fish Market is one of the oldest fish markets in the United States. In 2005 the market relocated to its new home in the Hunts Point Bronx “Food Hive”. The new 400,000-square-foot market sees up to two million pounds of fresh seafood arrive every day, making it the second largest fish market in the world (after Tokyo).
Features
- Choose from 14 different boxes. Select the quantity and frequency of delivery (1, 2, 4, or 8 weeks).
- As a subscriber, you save 5%.
- Can send as a gift or send a gift certificate and let them make their own choice.
- Subscribers get their own accounts. From the dashboard, you can:
- Skip upcoming deliveries
- Change the order charge date for your delivery
- Add or swap the items in your subscription
- Add one-time items to your seafood delivery
- Update delivery address info
- Update billing info
- Cancel your subscription
Shipping
Free shipping to some US states is available. Fulton Fish Market does not ship to Hawaii, Alaska or internationally. All shipping is done using FedEx.
Pricing
The minimum order is $75.

Sea to Table
Overview
After learning the ropes on fishing boats and living in fishing communities, Sean Dimin founded Sea to Table with his father and brothers. Sea to Table has garnered favorable press from Epicurious, bon appetit, Forbes National Geographic The New York Times, and PBS. It works with other socially-responsible organizations that care about the health of our oceans and the safety of our food.
To assure that their fish is fresh-caught, each package of fish includes a traceability label that lists where your seafood was caught, the catch method, and the best-by date. They’ve spent years developing relationships with suppliers on every U.S. coast, building the market for domestic seafood by delivering fresh and frozen fish to professional chefs across the country. Their home seafood delivery was started so that families across the United States can enjoy the very best catch.
While the vast majority of seafood sold in the United States is imported from overseas, and often comes from poorly regulated industrial farms, all Sea to Table seafood is wild caught from well-managed U.S. fisheries. Their fish is flash-frozen to preserve freshness.
Features
- When you sign up for a Sea to Table subscription, they’ll deliver sustainably sourced wild caught seafood right to your door at the frequency of your choosing (every 4, 6, or 8 weeks) for as long as you’d like.
- Digital Gift Cards never expire.
- You can also send an order as a gift.
- Each customer gets their own online account. Once logged in, you can:
- Edit the items in your subscription
- Skip the next delivery
- Change your next delivery date
- Change your delivery frequency
- Change your payment method or delivery address
- Add a discount code
- Pause or cancel your subscription
Shipping
At this time, they only ship within the continental United States. They do not ship to Canada, Hawaii, Puerto Rico, or Alaska.
They ship from a centralized cold storage facility in Virginia to most states.
Most shipments to AZ, CA, ID, NV, OR, and WA ship from their cold storage facility in Washington State.
- Orders of $99+ qualify for free standard shipping (after any discounts are applied).
- Orders of $50 – $98.99 are assessed a $30 shipping fee.
- Orders up to $49.99 are assessed a $45 shipping fee.
Pricing
The price depends on the seafood box you choose. Prices range from $16 to $195. There are 19 different boxes to choose from.

Sizzlefish
Overview
For 30 years Sizzlefish has supplied fish and wild caught seafood to the top natural and premium grocery companies in the US. From this history, the online version, Sizzlefish.com, was born. Their mission is simple: They want you to eat well and live better and enjoy both the health and performance benefits of fish. You can trust them to supply you with pure natural fish portions, tools and tips for quick easy preparation, and honest information about the benefits you are receiving from Sizzlefish products.
Features
- Each customer gets an online account where all aspects of their subscription can be managed.
- Choose from your favorite seafood to create your own box. You can switch it up at any time.
- You can build your own box by choosing from 18 different kinds of seafood or have Sizzlefish create a box for you.
- Choose from over fifteen different types of seafood including popular favorites like wild Alaskan seafood, shrimp, ahi tuna, and Maryland crab cakes.
- Their website contains tons of recipes, with new ones added weekly.
- Just want to make a purchase without setting up a subscription? No problem. They have 81 products you can buy individually online.
- You can send gifts. These range from physical gift cards to e-cards to seafood boxes. There are 24 gift choices.
Shipping
- Your subscription order will ship out with free shipping and arrive frozen.
- For individual orders shipping is free on orders over $100.
- Currently, they are able to ship only to continental US addresses.
- Standard shipping is UPS ground but you can expedite your seafood delivery by selecting another delivery option at check out.
Pricing
- Pricing depends on the box, the seafood selected, and the number of portions in the box.
- Prices range from $120 to $252.
- A 10% off coupon is offered.

Catch Sitka Seafoods
Overview
In 2018, Catch Sitka expanded its 20-year sport fishing business and created its own seafood company supplying pristine, nutritious, wild caught fish to wholesalers and restaurants.
2020 changed everything for Catch Sitka Seafoods and the world. With travel and restaurants shut down by the pandemic, the sport fishing and wholesale seafood business ground to a halt. They opened Catch Sitka Seafoods to consumers nationwide, creating boxes of the world’s most incredible fish, all wild caught by the local Sitka community.
As a seafood processor, Catch Sitka Seafoods recognizes its responsibility to the resource, to our fishermen, and to their community. They run Catch Sitka Seafoods with great care and intention. They believe that each fish deserves to be treated with a singular devotion to quality and the respect due to a wild creature, and that this dedication to respect, service, and connection extends all the way to our customers.
Their seafood comes with a 100% satisfaction guarantee. At every step of the process from fish to plate, they strive to honor their community, customers, and the environment.
Features
There are only 4 steps to get fresh Sitka fish to your door.
- Their fish is wild-caught by hook & line in the pristine waters of Sitka, Alaska using sustainable fishing practices.
- Immediately iced.
- Processed dock-side by artisans.
- Blast frozen to lock in flavor and sent straight to you.
- They have 7 boxes to choose from–each containing a different kind of seafood.
- For gifts, 5 gift boxes are available plus gift certificates ranging from $10 to $100.
- A free cooking guide comes in every box.
- Many incredible recipes can be found under the recipe tab on their website.
- Catch Sitka believes in sustainability, minimal processing, and getting seafood to customers in the best condition possible. This means that they do not pin bone their fish. The machine necessary to do this task creates a lot of damage to the flesh of the fish and adds to the waste remaining on the carcass. They don’t like this, they want to preserve the most usable flesh on our fish for their customers.
Shipping
- All orders are shipped in an insulated box using dry ice and ice gel packs. Vacuum-sealed packages are wrapped securely and placed on top of frozen ice gel packs, dry ice is then placed on top. The dry ice will evaporate in transit and your fish will arrive frozen solid at your doorstep.
- They ship everywhere in the United States, the only exception being a few remote areas in Alaska and Hawaii where next-day air shipping is unavailable.
- Shipping is $19.99.
Pricing
Box prices range from $46 to $207.

Lobster of the Month Club
Overview
Lobster of the Month Club has been featured on Good Morning America, The Early Show, Today, The Wall Street Journal, and USA Today. It is part of Amazing Clubs, founded in 2003, which has over 3 million customers and a wide array of monthly gift and subscription products. Amazing Clubs has been independently rated #1 for 7 years in a row with a better than 99% customer satisfaction rating.
Each month they’ll deliver a selection of 4 Maine lobster tails shipped ocean-fresh from the same waters that supply some of the most exclusive restaurants around the world. Their premium lobster tails average a generous 7 to 8 ounces and each has been hand-selected exclusively for their members.
Features
- Each month they’ll deliver a mouth-watering selection of delicious wild caught Maine lobster tails shipped fresh from the cold, clean waters of the North Atlantic Ocean.
- Each delivery includes four large tails (averaging 7-8 ounces each).
- You can send a gift announcement by mail or email or you can print it from your computer.
- Each monthly delivery includes their informative lobster lover’s newsletter, Fresh from the Ocean, with information about their monthly selections, fun lobster facts, and serving suggestions.
- You can choose from club durations of 3, 6, or 12 months. You can skip or pause a month.
Shipping
Free shipping in the continental U.S.
Pricing
The price per month depends on the club’s duration. The range is $138 to $140 per month.

Gourmet Seafood Box
Overview
Gourmet Seafood has served as direct importers and wholesale distributors since 2001. After two decades of purveying some of the best fillets in the world, they decided to at last tackle the industry’s biggest quandary: how to deliver truly fresh fish, to everyone that wants it, regardless of their location. They leveraged their extensive network of producers and packers and Gourmet Seafood Box was born.
Gourmet Seafood Box brings you and your family a generous helping of fresh-from-the-water seafood, hand-selected, perfectly portioned, and ready for any recipe. They work with some of the finest fisheries and fishmongers on the planet to secure an excellent product at an excellent price. Each fillet is flash-frozen the day of the catch to assure benchmark flavor and superior freshness.
Features
- They have 4 seafood boxes available as subscriptions.
- In addition, they have 17 different types of seafood that can be ordered individually.
- Orders are packed in a Styrofoam cooler with dry ice in an insulated bag to assure your fish arrives impeccably frozen.
- Their site has a large array of seafood recipes.
Shipping
- Shipping is free for all orders over $79 with the exception of Stone Crabs, which are shipped next day air.
- Shipping is limited to anywhere within the continental United States.
- See this map for shipping times by state.
Pricing
Prices depend on the box. The range is $89 to $169. Subscribers save 15%.

Seatopia
Overview
Seatopia is the first farm-to-table seafood cooperative. Only working with the “best-of-the-best” truly sustainable aquaculture farms, their direct sustainably sourced seafood supply chain values and incentivizes artisan quality production, fair labor practices, and environmental stewardship.
A social enterprise, Seatopia is dedicated to not only mitigating pressure on wild-caught fish through the advancement of truly sustainably sourced seafood, but also proactively investing at least one percent of sales into ocean conservation projects. Specifically, we are focused on helping promote, manage, and create new Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) or “Hope Spots”.
Features
- They call their monthly subscription “Collective Boxes” There are 3 sizes: 12, 18, or 24 servings.
- Unlike the other seafood companies I have reviewed, Seatopia does not supply fish that has been caught from the sea. Instead, their fish is sourced directly from artisan-quality farms. It is truly sustainably sourced seafood.
- Their farm partners never use hormones, preventative antibiotics, unethical practices, or GMO brood stock.
- To ensure everything they sell is genuinely clean, they submit a sample of every lot harvested to lab testing, and only offer the seafood that quantifies less than 0.1 PPM of Mercury in a Certificate of Analysis.
- This is truly the source of gourmet fish products. What was once only found on the menus of the finest farm-to-table restaurants, is now available delivered direct to your doorstep.
- Can choose between receiving a box every month or every two months.
- If kept in a stable deep chest freezer, Seatopia seafood will be good for 3 months.
- There is a vast number of recipes for many different fish on their website.
Shipping
Their seafood is delivered carbon neutral via UPS Priority overnight with carbon offset shipping, packaged in an environmentally-friendly cold chain, and a thermal cooler that is fully compostable.
Pricing
12 serving sample box: $200
18 serving box: $250
24 serving box: $300
Subscribers get 15% off
Shipping
They currently ship to all 50 U.S. States and Washington DC.

Fresh fish subscription box FAQs
1. What is the best seafood subscription box?
There is no one “best” seafood subscription box. However, some boxes may be better suited for certain types of seafood lovers than others. For example, if you are looking for a large variety of fresh, sustainable seafood options, Seatopia may be a better choice than some of the other boxes listed. If you are only interested in shipments of fresh fish, a company like Fulton Fish Market or Sizzlefish may be a better option.
2. How often do the different seafood subscription boxes send out shipments?
Each company has different options. The choices are generally every 4, 6, or 12 weeks.
3. How much does the best seafood subscription box cost?
The cost of the seafood subscription box will vary depending on which box you choose. I have provided a range of prices for each of the seven companies I have reviewed.
4. What type of seafood is included in the different seafood subscription boxes?
The type of seafood included in each box varies depending on the company. Some companies specialize in a certain type of seafood. However, most boxes include a variety of fresh fish, shellfish, and lobster–all wild caught.
5. How is the seafood packaged and shipped?
The seafood is typically packaged in a styrofoam cooler with dry ice and shipped via overnight UPS.
6. How long will the seafood last after it is received?
In general, if frozen and stored in a deep chest freezer, seafood will last for up to three months. If refrigerated upon arrival, seafood will last for approximately two weeks
7. What kind of recipes are available for the different types of seafood?
There are a ton of delicious recipes for all kinds of seafood. No need to reinvent the wheel here. Most companies have an extensive list of recipes available on their website.
Examples of the variety of seafood available
- Cherrystone clams: The tasty & nutritional powerhouse
- Calamari Fish: The Versatile & Tasty Seafood
- 11 Reasons Why PEI Mussels are the Best
- Halibut Cheeks: Answers to the 9 Top Questions
- 9 Things You Didn’t Know About Kumamoto Oysters

Bottom line
Seafood subscription boxes are a great way to get the freshest sustainably caught seafood delivered directly to your door. Most people don’t live on a U.S. coastline in Alaska or have access to a local fish mart.
Subscriptions are very flexible. You can change up your subscription or cancel at any time. Give one of the companies I have reviewed a try.